40 Year Est Pizzeria Restaurant For Sale in New York - 37464

Financing

$100,000 Down and Balance of $115k at 8% for 60 Months

Business Description

Own a 40 Year Pizzeria — Proven, Profitable, and Ready for Its Next Owner

Opportunities like this don’t come around often. In an industry known for resilience and long-term success—especially in Suffolk County, NY, where neighborhood pizzerias are part of the community fabric—this is your chance to step into a business with a track record that speaks for itself.

This established pizzeria has been operating successfully for over 40 years in the same location, with the same phone number, and only two owners throughout its entire history. That kind of consistency is rare—and valuable. It reflects a loyal customer base, a trusted name in the community, and a business model that works.

The operation is simple, efficient, and ideal for both experienced operators and first-time buyers looking to enter the pizza business. The current owner, who has been there for over 25 years, is retiring and is fully committed to a smooth transition. He will personally train the new owner from A to Z, sharing decades of knowledge to ensure continued success.

The location offers strong visibility and is supported by a favorable lease, making it an attractive long-term investment. Even more compelling, the seller is willing to hold a note for a qualified buyer with 50% down—making this a realistic path to ownership for the right individual or family.

Pizzerias have one of the strongest success track records in the restaurant industry—especially in markets like Suffolk County, where demand is consistent and community loyalty runs deep. When was the last time you saw a well-run local pizzeria close its doors?

This is more than a business—it’s a legacy opportunity.

First come, first served. Serious inquiries only.

Call for a private consultation today: Marie Goldstein(877) 735-5224

In addition, please register with the listing number above by going to vestedbb.com, enter this number into the search bar, expand the listing, click on “view free financials”, fill out the short contact form and you are registered. This is our electronic non-disclosure agreement.

Attention Business Owners:

We are always in search of quality businesses to list, so if you are thinking of selling your business or would like to acquire another business, please email us at listingmanager@vestedbb.com or call us at 1-877-735-5224 to discover the difference that is Vested Business Brokers.

Disclaimer: The financial information in this business listing has been provided by the Seller. Vested Business Brokers, Ltd. (VBB) has not independently verified this information. Therefore, we make no claims as to the accuracy of this financial summary. Vested recommends that you consult with an accountant, attorney and/or other professionals to represent and assist you in any business transaction. One of our associate brokers will arrange a meeting between you, your representatives, and the Seller, but they are not authorized to make any representations or warranties on behalf of the seller or VBB. You agree to hold Vested Business Brokers and its associated brokers harmless for any misrepresentations made by seller.